African climate campaigners have raised concerns that Brazil’s voluntary roadmap for moving away from fossil fuels could weaken pressure on wealthy countries to provide the finance and technology needed to support Africa’s energy transition.
The campaigners fear the plan could let developed countries avoid stronger commitments while leaving African economies to fund much of the transition themselves.
Brazil introduced the roadmap following last year’s COP30 climate summit in Belém. It aims to help countries implement the 2023 agreement reached at COP28 in Dubai to move away from fossil fuels in energy systems.
However, Philip Kilonzo of the Pan African Climate Justice Alliance (PACJA) said the roadmap’s voluntary nature could make it difficult to hold governments accountable.
“Developed countries actually praised Brazil for delivering that roadmap for transitioning away from fossil fuel because it’s voluntary, it’s non-binding,” he told a bird story agency in an exclusive interview at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey.
Kilonzo attended a high-level discussion on the proposal. He warned that the roadmap could replace efforts to secure a stronger international agreement. He said governments could announce transition plans without strong checks on whether they deliver on their promises or provide the support developing countries need.
Brazil published the roadmap on November 3 and presented it at COP31 on November 10. The document, developed under the COP30 Presidency, sits outside formal climate negotiations and creates no new binding commitments.
It provides a framework for countries to assess their dependence on fossil fuels, identify barriers to change and determine the investment needed for a transition.
The roadmap also considers energy demand and supply, government revenue dependence on fossil fuels and the cost of financing new energy systems.
The 2023 Dubai agreement called on countries to pursue a just, orderly and fair transition away from fossil fuels through national plans. However, it did not set binding deadlines for countries to phase out fossil fuels.
Under Article 9 of the Paris Agreement, developed countries are still required to provide financial support to developing nations for climate action, including reducing emissions and adapting to climate change.
Kilonzo fears that the voluntary roadmap could weaken pressure on wealthy countries to meet these responsibilities, leaving African governments without clear funding commitments. The concerns are particularly important for Africa, where more than 500 million people in sub-Saharan Africa still lack access to electricity.
The International Energy Agency’s 2025 electricity-access report estimated that Africa would need about $15 billion annually to achieve universal electricity access by 2035. However, commitments for new electricity connections in sub-Saharan Africa stood at less than $2.5 billion in 2023.

Chair of the African Group of Negotiators, Dr Antwi-Boasiako Amoah, said countries must be allowed to set transition timelines that reflect their development needs and dependence on fossil fuel revenues. He argued that African countries should not be expected to follow the same timetable as developed economies, which have benefited from decades of industrial growth.
“The biggest emitters have already developed, and we also have the right to develop,” he said.
Amoah also warned against leaving African fossil fuel resources unused without providing alternative revenue sources and the support needed to build cleaner energy systems. He argued that faster transition timelines would require developed countries to provide adequate finance and technology.
While African negotiators want flexibility to determine their own pace, Kilonzo is concerned that the voluntary approach could reduce pressure on wealthy nations to provide support.
PACJA Executive Director, Dr Mithika Mwenda, also stressed the need to consider Africa’s energy challenges.
“Much of Africa is not transitioning from an established system of universal, reliable and affordable energy,” he said.
Mwenda said African countries must expand their energy systems to meet growing demand while gradually reducing carbon emissions. He argued that progress should be measured not only by emissions cuts but also by improvements in electricity access, reliability, affordability and the productive use of energy.
He also called on wealthy countries to reduce their dependence on fossil fuels faster, citing their greater historical emissions and stronger financial and technological resources.
Brazil’s roadmap recognises that countries need different pathways to move away from fossil fuels. At its presentation, United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres urged governments to develop national plans with clear timelines, responsibilities and financing needs.
He also called for measurable progress by 2028 and urged developed countries and development banks to coordinate financial and technological support for the plans.
Mwenda said African countries need predictable, long-term funding that does not increase their debt burdens or take money away from essential public services.
Financing costs remain a major challenge. The IEA’s 2025 report found that the cost of capital for electricity-access projects was three to four times higher than for grid projects in advanced economies. It added that lower financing costs could reduce project expenses by 15 to 25 per cent, making electricity connections more affordable.
Reliable and affordable power is also important for Africa to benefit from its mineral resources.
An Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) report published in October found that much of the value in critical mineral supply chains comes from processing, refining and manufacturing.
However, these activities remain concentrated largely in Asia, particularly China. African countries need reliable electricity, affordable financing, infrastructure and skilled workers to expand these industries and earn more from their mineral resources.
Kilonzo said African governments should use global demand for their minerals to negotiate better deals on investment, technology and local production.
However, he questioned whether countries could secure these benefits while negotiating separate agreements with foreign governments and companies. He argued that acting individually could weaken their bargaining power.
Mwenda also called for more investment in local manufacturing, skills development and regional infrastructure. He warned that Africa could remain dependent on other economies even as the world adopts cleaner energy technologies.
“There is a risk that the transition will change the technologies powering the global economy without significantly changing Africa’s subordinate position within it,” he said.
African negotiators are also pushing for practical support through a separate just transition mechanism. Countries agreed at COP30 to develop the mechanism, with a decision on how to put it into operation expected at COP31.
The mechanism is expected to support international cooperation, technical assistance, skills development, and knowledge sharing.

The broader COP30 just transition agreement also addresses affordable energy, clean cooking, workers’ rights, technology transfer and financial support. It recognises that high debt levels can make it harder for developing countries to move to cleaner energy and calls for grants and loans with highly favourable terms.
Amoah said countries must receive the support needed to make the transition fair.
“So a transition without laid out means of implementation cannot be a just transition,” he said.
Mwenda proposed assessing the roadmap through three key questions: how countries can expand electricity access and productive capacity while reducing emissions, what support they need to achieve this, and how progress will be measured.
He said the assessment should track not only improvements in developing countries but also the finance and technology delivered by wealthy nations.
Brazilian officials have stressed that the roadmap is a call to action, not a document for formal negotiations. This means stronger commitments would have to come through other processes, including the proposed just transition mechanism.
Read More : Five Things to Know About ‘Grand Theft Auto’
However, African campaigners fear that while the voluntary approach may encourage more countries to participate, it could leave much of the responsibility for action and funding with individual governments.
For African countries, the outcome could shape access to electricity, industrial growth, fossil fuel revenues and investment for years to come.
Credit: Seth Onyango, Bird Story Agency.
Trending 







